How Marketing Performance Is Measured Differently Today
- TymFlo Content Team
- Dec 30, 2025
- 6 min read
Many business owners grew up with one main marketing question. How much traffic did we get. That question still matters, but it is no longer enough.
Google is changing how results look. More answers show up right inside the search page. That means people can get what they need without clicking a website.
Studies have tracked this shift for years. One well-known analysis found that for every 1,000 Google searches, only a few hundred clicks go to the open web, while many searches end with no click at all.
Another report showed organic clicks dropping year over year, while zero click searches rose between March 2024 and March 2025.
At the same time, AI search tools are growing. A Wall Street Journal report citing Datos showed AI searches rising as a share of US desktop search traffic, while traditional search still dominates overall.
So what does this mean for marketing performance.
It means we need a better scorecard. One that measures trust, intent, and outcomes. Not just clicks.
In this article, we will break down what to track now, and why.
Why traffic is no longer the main score
Traffic is easy to understand. More visitors sounds like progress.
But traffic can go up for the wrong reasons. It can also go down even when marketing is working.
Search results are taking more space
Google results pages now include featured snippets, maps, knowledge panels, and AI summaries. These features can answer questions before a click happens.
Bain’s research also points to this behavior at scale. Bain reported that many consumers rely on zero click results in a large share of searches, and that this can reduce organic web traffic. So a drop in clicks does not always mean a drop in demand.
It often means the decision is being made earlier, right on the results page.
AI search changes discovery behavior
AI tools can act like a shortcut. People ask a question, get a summary, then move on. The WSJ report described AI search growth and noted concerns from publishers and marketers about fewer click throughs.
This is why measuring only traffic can cause stress and wrong decisions.
What a modern performance scorecard looks like
A good scorecard answers one simple question.
Are the right people finding you, trusting you, and taking the next step.
That scorecard usually includes four buckets.
Visibility metrics
Visibility means showing up where decisions happen.
It includes search impressions, map visibility, branded searches, and how often your name appears in results.
These signals matter more when fewer users click.
TymFlo has been teaching this idea from a trust angle too. Their article Digital Bedside Manner Why Trust Not Traffic Drives Bookings explains why trust signals can convert better than raw traffic.
What to track for visibility
Track impressions, not just clicks. Track which pages show in search. Track whether your Google Business profile shows up for local intent.
Also track branded search growth. When more people search your name, it usually means your awareness is rising.
Engagement metrics that show intent
Engagement is not likes for the sake of likes.
Engagement that matters is the kind that shows intent.
Examples include time on a service page, scroll depth, form starts, and booking page views.
If traffic drops but the people who visit are more qualified, your business can still grow.
A simple way to think about engagement
If a visitor spends time on pricing, services, and booking, that is high intent.
If a visitor bounces from a blog page in five seconds, that is low intent.
This is why sessions and bounce rate alone are not enough.
Conversion metrics that tie to real outcomes
Conversions are actions that move business forward.
For service businesses, conversions usually include calls, form submissions, appointment bookings, quote requests, and direction clicks.
The goal is not to get more clicks. The goal is to get more right-fit inquiries.
TymFlo talks about building sites that support this outcome. Their post Web Design Secrets That Turn Visitors Into Clients focuses on making the next step clear, which is a core part of conversion performance.
What to track for conversions
Track conversions by channel. Track cost per lead if you run ads. Track lead quality if you can. Even a simple tag system helps.
Also track conversion rate, not only volume. A higher conversion rate often beats a higher traffic number.
Trust metrics that explain why people choose you
Trust is harder to measure, but it shows up in patterns.
It shows up in review volume and review quality. It shows up in branded searches. It shows up in repeat visits and return bookings.
It also shows up in email opens and replies, when email is used well.
TymFlo’s post Smarter SEO Moves For Doctors Lawyers And Leaders In 2025 explains that modern SEO is tied to clarity and credibility, not just rankings.
What to track for trust
Track review count changes month to month. Track average rating. Track how often your name is searched. Track returning visitors. Track email engagement.
If your trust signals rise, conversions usually follow.
The big shift
We moved from measuring attention to measuring decisions.
This is the core change.
Traffic measures attention.
Modern performance measures decisions and readiness to buy.
This change is not a guess. It matches the way search behavior is trending.
SparkToro’s 2024 analysis showed a large share of searches do not send clicks to the open web. Search Engine Land’s reporting showed organic click activity declining year over year, with zero click searches rising in the same period. Bain’s research also connected zero click behavior to reduced organic traffic.
So marketers have to adapt.
What businesses should do differently
This is not about chasing every new tool.
It is about tightening the system.
Make your presence clearer in search
When people see your brand in results, they should understand what you do fast.
That means clear service titles, clear location signals, and clear trust elements.
A strong Google Business profile matters. Accurate categories matter. Good photos matter. Reviews matter.
Build pages that answer the next question
If AI summaries reduce casual clicks, the clicks you do get will be more serious.
Those visitors will want fast answers.
They will look for pricing signals, process, timelines, proof, and next steps.
If your pages make them work too hard, you lose them.
Track quality, not just quantity
A smaller number of leads can be better, if they are higher quality.
This is why you want to track what happens after the lead comes in.
Which channel sends the best clients. Which pages lead to booked calls. Which campaigns lead to repeat business.
Use benchmarks carefully
Benchmarks can help, but they can also mislead.
A 2 percent conversion rate could be great in one industry and weak in another.
A 30 percent email open rate could be average or excellent depending on the list.
TymFlo shared a real example of strong email performance in their trust focused post, with open rates reported above typical healthcare benchmarks in that case study context.
So use benchmarks as a guide, not a verdict.
A practical way to report performance today
If you need a simple reporting structure, use this order.
1 Visibility
Are we showing up more often in the right places.
2 Engagement
Are the right people taking interest and reading deeper.
3 Conversions
Are they taking the next step and contacting you.
4 Trust
Are signals of confidence rising over time.
You can still report traffic, but it becomes supporting data, not the headline.
The bottom line
Marketing performance is measured differently today because discovery happens differently today.
More people get answers without clicks. AI search tools are also growing and changing the path people take.
So the best measurement is not just traffic.
It is visibility, intent, outcomes, and trust.
If you want to go deeper into this direction, these TymFlo posts connect well with this shift.
When you measure the right things, marketing becomes calmer. You stop chasing noise. You start tracking what actually brings clients through the door.
Comments